Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Top 8 Girls Tonight!

Girls go first again this week! I like these shows with less time, no BS intros and such.

Katie Stevens - Was kind of boring, not badly sung but at this point nothing that would make you feel she needed to be kept around. With her also going first, she definitely is in trouble.

Siobhan Magnus - She sang House of the Rising Sun. It was very good, not as blow away as last week but she is definitely building a nice little body of work. All the judges loved it except Simon (he didn't hate it). I think Simon's issue with Siobhan is she is strange (Simon likes to see exactly what you are getting, like a Carrie Underwood) and I think he also was doing a bit of reverse psychology so her fans didn't think she was too safe.

Lacey Brown - Also pretty good. Also very sleepy. (The Theme for today is Sing Beautiful but Boring.) Probably one of her best performances. The judges liked it a lot. Lacey was one of the contestants that came into this week needing to be good and she was.

Katelyn Epperly - Sings I FEEL THE EARTH MOVE. I love how she looks and hate the song choice, which is where I was last week with Michelle as she got knocked out. Ehh...not awful but nothing special at all. There is no chance of her escaping without at least one judge mentioning karaoke. They do, they are pretty harsh, Kara feels she is not competing (Kara has become the total anti-Paula, i almost wish Paula was here, they would have had an enormous fight at some point.

Didi Benami - Here with some Fleetwood Mac. That was really good! This is what I liked about Didi at first. Randy doesn't like it that much (did they tell him he only can like one thing per episode?) Simon REALLY liked it. YAH, Didi is in good standing now. She was in danger after last week. Not so this week (i think!)

Paige Miles - She is dull again even on this show where slow seems to almost be the theme. Please send her home. That is all I have to say.

Crystal Bowersox - Sings "Give Me One Reason" by Tracy Chapman. Very good! Simon says everyone is chasing her now. I'm not sure I agree with that 100% but she certainly is a strong contender at this point.

Lilly Scott - She is good again but it's becoming clear everything she sings will sound exactly the same. If she can't do a little more than she's just going to be "there" on the show, no chance to do real well, just biding time till she is gone.

I think Paige and Lacey are gone. I think Katie has some fans who will push her through. We shall see soon...

Tommorrow - the men go!

1 comment:

  1. Strange but really good song choice by Siobhan...she sounded great!

    ReplyDelete